In this post, we will explore Lisa Feldman Barrett's lesson "The Origin of Feeling" from her book, How Emotions Are Made. For a more comprehensive understanding and to experience the full depth of Barrett's insights, we highly encourage readers to purchase the book and its Audible narration, personally delivered by the author, which provides an engaging and detailed exploration of these fascinating concepts.
Introduction
Think about the last time you experienced a vivid sunrise or sipped a cold glass of water when you were hot and sweaty. These moments of everyday delight are direct results of interoceptive processes. On the other hand, unpleasant feelings, such as being sick with a cold or feeling upset after an argument, also stem from interoception. The brain constantly receives and interprets signals from within the body, creating a spectrum of basic feelings ranging from pleasant to unpleasant and from calm to jittery. These basic feelings flow like a current through every waking moment of life, providing a continuous backdrop to our experiences and interactions. They serve as a fundamental layer upon which more complex emotions are constructed, influencing how we react to and interpret the world around us.
Interoception and Emotion
Interoception is a core ingredient of emotion, similar to how flour and water are core ingredients of bread. These interoceptive feelings are simpler than full-blown emotional experiences but are fundamental to them. For instance, the calm feeling you might get from taking a deep breath and the jittery feeling after drinking too much coffee are products of interoception. These basic feelings provide a foundation upon which more complex emotions like joy, sadness, or anger are built. Understanding interoception helps us appreciate how these basic sensations contribute to the rich tapestry of our emotional lives. They form the raw materials that our brains use to construct more nuanced and varied emotional states, shaping our responses to different situations and contexts. By tracing the origins of these feelings to interoception, we gain a deeper understanding of how our bodies and minds are interconnected in creating our emotional experiences.
The Predictive Brain
The brain is not merely reactive; it is constantly predicting. Traditional views of the brain saw it as a reactive organ that responds to stimuli from the outside world. However, modern neuroscience reveals that the brain is continuously active, generating predictions about sensory input and bodily states. This intrinsic activity is structured by collections of neurons that consistently fire together, forming intrinsic networks. These networks operate much like sports teams, with different players (neurons) participating at different times to achieve the same overall function. This predictive process is fundamental to how we perceive the world and experience our emotions. It explains why our perceptions and reactions are often immediate and seamless, as the brain anticipates and prepares for incoming sensory information. By understanding this predictive nature, we can better grasp the complexities of human cognition and emotion and how our brains construct our reality.
Simulations and Sensations
Intrinsic brain activity is not random but organized into structured networks that produce simulations. These simulations are the basis for dreams, daydreams, imagination, and mind wandering. They also create every sensation we experience, including interoceptive sensations, which are the origins of our most basic pleasant, unpleasant, calm, and jittery feelings. For example, when you imagine a red apple, your brain's neurons in the visual cortex change their firing patterns to simulate the apple. This process is the same when you actually see an apple in real life; the brain predicts and then confirms the visual input. These continuous simulations form the basis of how we interpret and interact with the world. They allow the brain to fill in gaps and create a coherent experience from fragmented sensory inputs. This continuous simulation helps explain why our experiences are so rich and detailed, even when the sensory information we receive is incomplete or ambiguous.
The Brain as an Active Predictor
The brain's ability to predict and simulate goes beyond simple reactions to stimuli. It uses past experiences to inform its predictions, constantly updating its internal model of the world. This means that the brain is always working proactively, not just reactively. For example, when you hear a loud bang, your brain quickly predicts what might have caused it based on past experiences, such as a door slamming, a balloon popping, or a gunshot. This predictive activity helps the brain to process sensory input more efficiently and prepare appropriate responses. The brain's predictions are not limited to external stimuli but also include interoceptive predictions, anticipating internal bodily changes. This ongoing predictive process ensures that the brain is always one step ahead, ready to interpret and respond to the ever-changing environment.
The Role of Past Experiences
Past experiences play a crucial role in shaping the brain's predictions. Each sensory input is interpreted based on previous encounters, allowing the brain to make educated guesses about the current situation. This process is evident when we misinterpret stimuli due to incorrect predictions. For instance, seeing a coiled rope in a dimly lit area might cause your brain to predict a snake, leading to a momentary feeling of fear. The fear dissipates once the brain receives more information and corrects its prediction. This constant updating of predictions based on sensory input and past experiences helps the brain to fine-tune its responses, reducing the likelihood of errors over time. Understanding this mechanism highlights the importance of experiences in shaping our perceptions and reactions, demonstrating how the brain continuously learns and adapts.
Prediction Errors and Adjustments
Prediction errors occur when the brain's predictions do not match the actual sensory input. These errors are not failures but opportunities for the brain to learn and adjust its predictions. When a prediction error is detected, the brain updates its internal model to better align with reality. This process is crucial for learning and adaptation. For example, if you expect to taste something sweet but instead taste something sour, your brain quickly adjusts its prediction about the food's flavor. This adjustment helps refine future predictions, making them more accurate. Prediction errors are a normal part of the brain's functioning, allowing it to continuously improve its understanding of the world and its ability to respond appropriately.
The Brain's Default Mode
The brain's default mode is to generate predictions, even in the absence of external stimuli. This intrinsic activity is responsible for many aspects of our mental life, including daydreams, imagination, and mind wandering. These internal simulations allow the brain to practice and refine its predictions, preparing it for future encounters. For example, when you daydream about a conversation with a friend, your brain simulates various scenarios and responses, helping you prepare for actual interactions. This default mode of prediction ensures that the brain is always engaged in meaningful activity, even when not directly responding to the outside world. It highlights the brain's remarkable ability to generate complex mental experiences from within.
Interoceptive Predictions and Emotions
Interoceptive predictions play a significant role in the creation of emotions. When the brain predicts changes in the body's internal state, it generates interoceptive sensations that form the basis of our feelings. For example, the feeling of anxiety might arise from predictions about increased heart rate and muscle tension in response to a perceived threat. These interoceptive predictions are continuously updated based on sensory input, ensuring that our emotional responses are appropriate to the current situation. This process underscores the close relationship between bodily states and emotional experiences, demonstrating how the brain integrates internal and external information to generate feelings.
The Interoceptive Network
The interoceptive network in the brain is composed of regions that predict and monitor internal bodily states. This network includes areas such as the insula and anterior cingulate cortex, which are involved in processing interoceptive signals and generating predictions. These regions work together to maintain the body's internal environment within optimal ranges. For example, if the body needs more glucose, the interoceptive network predicts sensations of hunger, prompting you to eat. This network regulates bodily functions and contributes to our emotional experiences by generating the basic feelings of pleasantness, unpleasantness, arousal, and calmness. Understanding the interoceptive network helps us appreciate the complexity of the brain's role in maintaining homeostasis and generating emotions.
Body Budgeting
Body budgeting refers to the brain's management of the body's energy resources. This process involves predicting the body's energy needs and allocating resources accordingly. For instance, when you plan to exercise, your brain predicts the increased energy demand and adjusts your body budget by mobilizing glucose and oxygen. This predictive management ensures that the body has the resources it needs to function efficiently. The brain's body budgeting is closely linked to interoception, as it relies on accurate predictions of internal states to maintain balance. This concept highlights the brain's role in regulating our emotions and overall physical well-being.
Interoceptive Sensations and Consciousness
Interoceptive sensations are fundamental to our conscious experience. These sensations provide a continuous stream of information about the state of our body, influencing our feelings and perceptions. For example, the sensation of a pounding heart can contribute to feelings of anxiety, while a calm, steady heartbeat might be associated with feelings of relaxation. These interoceptive signals are integrated with sensory input from the external world, shaping our overall experience of reality. This integration demonstrates how closely linked our physical and emotional states are, with interoceptive sensations playing a key role in how we perceive and interact with the world.
Affect: The General Sense of Feeling
Affect refers to the general sense of feeling that we experience throughout the day. It is not as complex as emotions but provides a basic sense of how we feel at any given moment. Affect has two main dimensions: valence (pleasantness or unpleasantness) and arousal (calmness or agitation). These dimensions help us navigate our environment by providing quick, intuitive assessments of our experiences. For example, feeling a sense of pleasantness might encourage us to continue a particular activity, while a sense of unpleasantness might prompt us to stop. Understanding affect helps us appreciate the continuous stream of feelings that influence our decisions and actions, highlighting the foundational role of interoception in our emotional lives.
The Affective Circumplex
The affective circumplex is a model used to describe the continuous nature of affect. It represents affect as a circular space with two dimensions: valence and arousal. This model helps us understand how different feelings are related and how they can change over time. For instance, feelings of excitement can be placed in the high-arousal, pleasant quadrant, while feelings of calmness can be placed in the low-arousal, pleasant quadrant. This model illustrates the fluidity of affect, showing how our feelings can shift based on changes in our internal and external environments. The affective circumplex provides a useful framework for exploring the nuances of our emotional experiences and understanding the role of interoception in shaping them.
Affective Realism
Affective realism is the phenomenon where our feelings influence our perception of the world. This means we often interpret sensory information based on our feelings rather than objective reality. For example, if you are feeling anxious, you might perceive a neutral facial expression as threatening. This bias can significantly impact our interactions and decision-making. Understanding affective realism highlights the importance of being aware of our internal states and how they can color our perceptions. By recognizing this tendency, we can work towards more accurate and balanced interpretations of our experiences.
The Illusion of Free Will
The illusion of free will refers to the idea that our decisions and actions are often driven by unconscious predictions rather than conscious intent. This concept challenges the traditional view of free will, suggesting that our brains predict and initiate actions before we become aware of them. For instance, when you reach out to pick up a cup, your brain has already predicted and initiated the movement before you consciously decide to do so. This understanding emphasizes the role of interoception and prediction in our behavior, showing that our actions are deeply influenced by automatic processes within the brain.
Impact on Decision-Making
Interoception and affect play a crucial role in decision-making. Our feelings provide important information about our internal states, guiding our choices and actions. For example, a feeling of unease might prompt us to avoid a particular situation, while a feeling of excitement might encourage us to pursue an opportunity. This influence is evident in various contexts, from everyday decisions to significant life choices. Recognizing the impact of interoception on decision-making can help us make more informed and balanced choices, considering both our internal states and external factors.
Social Interactions and Interoception
Interoception also affects our social interactions. Our internal states influence how we perceive and respond to others. For example, when we are relaxed and calm, we might be more open and empathetic in our interactions. Conversely, when we are stressed or anxious, we might be more defensive or reactive. Understanding this connection helps us appreciate the role of interoception in shaping our social behavior and relationships. By being aware of our internal states, we can improve our interactions with others and build more positive and supportive relationships.
Interoception and Mental Health
Interoception is closely linked to mental health. Dysregulation of interoceptive processes can contribute to various mental health conditions, such as anxiety and depression. For instance, individuals with anxiety might have heightened interoceptive sensitivity, leading to an exaggerated perception of bodily sensations. This heightened sensitivity can create a feedback loop, intensifying feelings of anxiety. Understanding the role of interoception in mental health can inform new approaches to treatment, focusing on regulating interoceptive processes to improve emotional well-being.
The Role of Interoception in Therapy
Interoception can be a valuable focus in therapy. Techniques that enhance interoceptive awareness, such as mindfulness and body-focused therapies, can help individuals better understand and regulate their internal states. Individuals can learn to respond to their feelings more adaptively by increasing awareness of bodily sensations. This approach can be particularly effective for individuals with conditions like anxiety and depression, where interoceptive dysregulation plays a key role. Integrating interoceptive awareness into therapeutic practices offers a promising avenue for improving mental health and emotional regulation.
The Influence of Culture on Interoception
Cultural factors can influence interoception and the way we experience emotions. Different cultures have varying norms and expectations regarding emotional expression and bodily awareness. For example, Eastern cultures often emphasize mindfulness and the integration of mind and body, which can enhance interoceptive awareness. In contrast, Western cultures might focus more on cognitive aspects of emotions, potentially leading to less attention to bodily sensations. Understanding these cultural differences can help us appreciate the diverse ways in which interoception shapes emotional experiences across different societies.
Interoception and Technology
Advances in technology are providing new ways to study and enhance interoception. Wearable devices that monitor physiological signals, such as heart rate and skin conductance, can provide real-time feedback on interoceptive states. This information can be used to develop personalized interventions to improve emotional regulation and well-being. For example, biofeedback training can help individuals learn to control their physiological responses, leading to better stress and anxiety management. As technology continues to evolve, it offers exciting possibilities for enhancing our understanding and regulation of interoception.
Future Directions in Interoception Research
Research on interoception is rapidly evolving, with discoveries shedding light on the complex interactions between the brain, body, and emotions. Future studies will likely explore the neural mechanisms underlying interoceptive processes in greater detail and their role in various mental and physical health conditions. Advances in imaging techniques and computational models will enhance our ability to study interoception in real time, providing deeper insights into how these processes influence our daily lives. This ongoing research has the potential to revolutionize our understanding of emotions and inform new approaches to treatment and well-being.
Conclusion
The origin of feelings lies in the brain's intricate interoceptive processes. By continuously monitoring and predicting internal bodily states, the brain generates the basic feelings of pleasure, displeasure, arousal, and calmness that form the foundation of our emotional experiences. These interoceptive sensations influence our thoughts, decisions, and actions, demonstrating the profound interconnectedness of our bodies and minds. Understanding interoception offers valuable insights into the nature of our emotions and the ways in which we perceive and interact with the world. As research in this field advances, it holds the promise of new approaches to enhancing emotional regulation, mental health, and overall well-being. By recognizing the central role of interoception, we can better navigate our emotional lives and foster a deeper connection between mind and body.
Glossary
affective realism: the phenomenon where a person's feelings influence their perception of the world, leading them to interpret sensory information based on their emotional state rather than objective reality.
affective circumplex: a model that describes the continuous nature of affect, representing feelings as a circular space with dimensions of valence (pleasantness or unpleasantness) and arousal (calmness or agitation).
arousal: a dimension of affect that indicates the level of physiological and psychological activation, ranging from calm to agitated.
body budgeting: the brain's management of the body's energy resources, predicting and allocating these resources to maintain optimal bodily function.
emotion: complex mental states involving feelings, thoughts, and behavioral responses, often linked to specific interoceptive sensations.
free will, illusion of: the concept that decisions and actions are often driven by unconscious predictions rather than conscious intent, challenging the traditional view of free will.
interoception: the brain's representation of internal bodily states, including sensations from organs, hormones, and the immune system, forming the basis of simple feelings.
intrinsic brain activity: the continuous, structured activity within the brain that generates predictions and simulations, even in the absence of external stimuli.
neural networks: collections of interconnected neurons that consistently fire together, forming the basis for intrinsic brain activity and predictions.
prediction error: a mismatch between the brain's predictions and actual sensory input, leading to adjustments in the brain's internal model to better align with reality.
prediction loop: the process by which the brain's predictions are compared to sensory input, generating interoceptive sensations and adjusting predictions based on prediction errors.
primary interoceptive cortex: q region of the brain that represents sensations inside the body and compares predicted interoceptive sensations with actual sensory input.
simulation: the brain's generation of mental experiences, such as dreams, daydreams, and imagination, based on predictions and past experiences.
valence: a dimension of affect that indicates the level of pleasantness or unpleasantness of a feeling.
References
Barrett, L. F. (2017). How emotions are made: The secret life of the brain. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.
Craig, A. D. (2009). How do you feel—now? The anterior insula and human awareness. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 10(1), 59-70.
Damasio, A. R. (1994). Descartes’ error: Emotion, reason, and the human brain. Penguin Books.
Goleman, D. (1995). Emotional intelligence: Why it can matter more than IQ. Bantam Books.
Russell, J. A. (1980). A circumplex model of affect. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 39(6), 1161-1178.
Sagan, C. (1977). The dragons of Eden: Speculations on the evolution of human intelligence. Random House.
Smith, R., & Lane, R. D. (2015). The neural basis of emotional awareness: Evidence for the co-emergence of subcortical and interoceptive networks. Frontiers in Psychology, 6, 1830.
Learn More
Support Our Friends at ISNR and AAPB
Comments